Joseph Woll Toronto Maple Leafs

Maple Leafs at Panthers: Key Betting Factors & Game 3 Pick

By Rich Crew
Date: 09/05/2025 7:00 pm
Location: Amerant Bank Arena
TV: TruTV

Betting Odds



Moneyline: Maple Leafs +190 / Panthers -235
Total: 6.0 (Over -105, Under -115)

What are the crucial factors to consider when betting on the Maple Leafs vs. Panthers game tonight (7:00 PM ET)? We examine Joseph Woll’s recent play, Toronto’s road offense, Florida’s home defense, and significant betting trends at Amerant Bank Arena before revealing our top pick for May 9th.

Sharp Money Take

The line opened with Florida at -220 and has seen a significant move to -235, showing some sharp interest on the Panthers despite their recent struggles. However, there’s been steady resistance at this number, with money coming in on Toronto at +190. The total has stayed firm at 6 with no meaningful movement, though the slight juice favoring the under suggests some sharp interest in a potentially tight, defensive game. With 65% of tickets on Florida but only 55% of handle, there’s indication of some smart money finding value with Toronto.

Key Matchup Analysis

Joseph Woll has been absolutely standing on his head lately for Toronto, posting a 3-1-1 record in his last five starts despite facing high shot volumes. His .907 save percentage on the season doesn’t tell the full story of his recent form, as he’s been the backbone of Toronto’s playoff push. Woll is likely to get the start with Anthony Stolarz listed as day-to-day with an upper-body injury.

Florida’s offense generates a high volume of shots (31.1 per game, ranking among league leaders) but faces a Toronto defense that’s been surprisingly stingy, allowing just 2.82 goals per game. The Leafs’ road penalty kill has been solid at 79.05%, which could neutralize Florida’s somewhat mediocre home power play (19.01%).

Toronto’s road offense has been cooking all season, scoring 3.39 goals per game away from home (1st in NHL). They’ll face Florida’s typically strong home defense (allowing 2.47 goals per game), setting up a classic strength-vs-strength battle.

Situational Factors

Toronto has won the last two meetings against Florida, both at home, with scores of 4-3 and 5-4. They’ve shown they can hang with the Panthers in high-scoring affairs. Despite recent losses to Ottawa, the Leafs are still 6-3-1 in their last 10 games overall and an impressive 3-2-1 in their last 6 road games.

Florida has been inconsistent lately, posting a 5-5 record in their last 10 and coming off two straight losses to Toronto. While they boast a strong 16-4 straight-up record in their last 20 home games, they’ve struggled on the puckline at home lately, going 3-6 in their last 9.

The head-to-head trends favor Florida at home historically (5-1 SU in last 6 against Toronto), but the Leafs’ current form can’t be ignored. Eight of the last 10 meetings have featured 5+ total goals, though the Under is historically 12-5 in the last 17 meetings.

Statistical Edges

Toronto’s road scoring prowess gives them a significant edge, with their 3.39 goals per game away from home leading the NHL. The Leafs are also converting 26.96% of their power plays on the road (5th in league), a potential difference-maker against Florida’s middle-of-the-pack home penalty kill (78.79%).

While the Maple Leafs have had some road struggles against Ottawa recently, they’re still 5-1 on the puckline in their last 6 road games according to the betting trends data. Meanwhile, Florida has struggled dramatically on the puckline, going 8-17 in their last 25 games overall.

With Toronto winning two straight against Florida by one goal each, they’ve shown they can keep games tight. The Leafs’ road differential of +0.32 goals per game shows they’re comfortable in hostile environments.

Leafs vs. Panthers Free Pick

There’s serious value on Toronto at this price. With Woll playing at a high level and the Leafs’ offense firing on all cylinders on the road, they’re fully capable of stealing a game in Florida. The Panthers have been overvalued by the market lately, going just 8-17 ATS in their last 25, while Toronto continues to exceed expectations on the road.

I’m putting 2 units on Toronto ML +190 as my primary play. Despite their recent losses to Ottawa, the Leafs have shown they can beat Florida head-to-head, and Woll gives them a fighting chance as a significant underdog. For more conservative bettors, Toronto +1.5 (-140) is worth 1 unit given the Leafs’ ability to keep games close.

The total is tricky with recent head-to-head games going over while the longer historical trend favors unders. If forced to play it, I’d lean under based on Woll’s recent form, but this is primarily a moneyline opportunity on the underdog.

Free Pick: Take the Maple Leafs +190
Bovada

SOLID 50% BONUS - UP TO $250 FREE!

NHL Free Picks

Betting NHL Individual Team Totals

Betting NHL Individual Team Totals

Along with money line odds for the favorite and underdog in a matchup, betting the OVER/UNDER on total goals scored is the most popular way to bet on any NHL game. In an effort to spice things up a bit, certain online sportsbooks will diversify the options for betting...

Betting NHL Individual Team Totals

Finding the Best Value in NHL Playoff Game Props

The quest for this year's NHL Stanley Cup is underway, with action heating up with each passing round of best-of-seven series matchups. As a supplement to the money line, total, and puck line for each game, online books such as Bovada will release a complete set of...

Betting NHL Individual Team Totals

NHL Final Prop Bets – Exact Matchup Odds

The NHL regular season is rapidly coming to a close to set up the 16 teams that will square off in the 2020 Stanley Cup Playoffs. This is the second season that every hockey fan and bettor has been waiting for. There is nothing more exciting that postseason play in...

Betting NHL Individual Team Totals

2020 Stanley Cup Championship Props

The race is officially on to this season's NHL Stanley Cup Championship coming off January's All-Star break. Going back to last year's run, it was quickly proven that success in the regular season does not always carry over to the playoffs with a number of first-round...

Betting The NHL After The All-Star Break – The Bettors Edge

Betting The NHL After The All-Star Break – The Bettors Edge

February marks the beginning of the stretch run to the NHL’s Stanley Cup Playoffs that get underway in early April. Over the next two months, the field for this season's race to the Cup will also separate the genuine contenders from the other pretenders, or at least...

BEST SPORTSBOOK BONUSES

Stop wasting money! Start receiving at 30% Rebate at Betanysports

YES! There are still online sportsbooks where your credit card will work! You get a 50% bonus as well! –> Bovada

Deposit $100 to $1000 and get a MASSIVE 50% Sign-on bonus! MyBookie