Marcus Stroman NY Yankees Starting Pitcher

Yankees vs. Pirates Over/Under Analysis & Pick

By Rich Crew
Date: 05/04/2025 4:05 pm
Location: PNC Park
TV: MLB TV

Betting Odds



Moneyline: Yankees -160/Pirates +135
Runline: Yankees -1.5 (-105)/Pirates +1.5 (-115)
Total: 9.5 (Over +100/Under -120)

The Yankees are rolling into PNC Park with their bats absolutely cooking, putting up 9+ runs in four of their seven games this season. With yesterday’s 9-4 Yankees win already in the books and the wind set to blow out again, this total looks way off considering what we’re seeing from both squads early this spring.

Sharp Money Take

The total opened at 9 and has been nudged up to 9.5 with plus money on the over, suggesting some reverse line movement. The sharps aren’t rushing to the window on either side yet, but with the Yankees crushing overs at a 5-2 clip this season, there’s serious value on the high side of this number.

Key Matchup Analysis

Bailey Falter takes the hill for Pittsburgh, and the southpaw got absolutely torched in his only appearance against the Yankees last September, coughing up 4 runs in just 3 innings. His 4.00 ERA might look decent on paper, but he’s sporting a troubling 1-4 record in his last 5 starts, and that Yankees lineup is absolutely lethal against lefties.
The Yankees counter with Marcus Stroman, who hasn’t been producing quality starts lately. His 4.91 runs allowed per 9 innings isn’t inspiring confidence, especially with Pittsburgh’s offense showing signs of life yesterday despite their overall struggles (2.88 runs per game).

Situational Factors

The Yankees are 7-3 to the over in their last 10 games and have gone over in 5 of their 7 games this season. They’re absolutely mashing right now, with offensive explosions of 9, 9, 12, and 20 runs already this season. Meanwhile, Pittsburgh pitching has yielded 5 runs per game on average.
This also sets up as a perfect bounce-back spot for the Pirates’ offense. After seeing Yankees pitching yesterday, they should have a better approach today, especially with their backs against the wall at 2-6 on the season.

Statistical Edges

The numbers are screaming over in this matchup:

  • Yankees scoring 8.86 runs per game (2nd MLB)
  • Pirates allowing 5.00 runs per game (22nd MLB)
  • Pittsburgh’s starting pitching has a bloated 5.09 ERA with a troubling 1.43 WHIP
  • The Yankees bullpen has been vulnerable with a 5.47 ERA
  • Falter’s last appearance vs. NYY: 3 IP, 4 ER, 3 BB, 1 HR (20.7 pitches per inning)

Yankees vs. Pirates O/U Pick

This total at 9.5 is flat-out disrespectful to what these offenses are capable of. The Yankees lineup is absolutely raking with 9+ runs in 57% of their games this season, and while Pittsburgh’s offense has been quiet, they showed signs of life yesterday against a better Yankees starter. Both bullpens have vulnerabilities that can be exploited in the later innings, and with favorable hitting conditions at PNC Park today, we’re looking at a potential shootout.
Play: OVER 9.5 (+100) – 2 Units
For a secondary play, consider the Yankees team total over 5.5 runs. They’ve been an absolute wagon offensively, and Falter has struggled against them historically. New York’s bats are too hot right now to project them for fewer than 6 runs against a vulnerable Pirates pitching staff.

Free Pick: Take the Over 9.5 +100
Bovada

SOLID 50% BONUS - UP TO $250 FREE!

MLB Free Picks

Bet on Starting Pitcher Value With MLB Five-Inning Lines

Bet on Starting Pitcher Value With MLB Five-Inning Lines

Similar to betting the first half of an NFL football game, an MLB five-inning line covers the first half of action in a baseball game. Since baseball betting lines, in general, are heavily weighted on each team's starting pitcher, their impact on the game's outcome...

Betting MLB Dime Lines at Select Online Sportsbooks

Betting MLB Dime Lines at Select Online Sportsbooks

Baseball is back on the betting board at your favorite online sportsbook. One of the most popular ways to bet on the games is by using the posted money line odds. An MLB money line handicaps the straight-up result for a game by increasing the financial risk to bet on...

Betting MLB Win Totals

Betting MLB Win Totals

One of the most popular betting props ahead of any MLB regular seasons is on the odds for each team’s projected win total. Given that the schedule covers 162 games, there can be a rather wide margin of error in any projected total. Going through the list of each MLB...

Betting the OVER/UNDER on MLB Props for Home Runs and Total Wins

Betting the OVER/UNDER on MLB Props for Home Runs and Total Wins

With spring training underway for all 30 MLB teams, there is a renewed interest in betting the posted props for individual player performances in the regular season. Options like which slugger hits the most home runs and which ace has the most wins are fun and...

Betting the OVER/UNDER on MLB Props for Home Runs and Total Wins

Betting Value in 2020 MLB World Series Futures

Spring training is underway as preparations for a new MLB season take place in the Grapefruit League throughout Florida and the Cactus League in the southern part of Arizona. Opening Day is about a month away at the end of March. While all 30 teams are working towards...

BEST SPORTSBOOK BONUSES

Stop wasting money! Start receiving at 30% Rebate at Betanysports

YES! There are still online sportsbooks where your credit card will work! You get a 50% bonus as well! –> Bovada

Deposit $100 to $1000 and get a MASSIVE 50% Sign-on bonus! MyBookie