Rafael Devers Boston Red Sox

Mets vs. Red Sox: Expert MLB Picks & Predictions for May 20th at Fenway

By Darin Zank

After taking the first game of this three-game set at Fenway Park Monday night, the Red Sox meet the Mets again Tuesday night.

Walker Buehler (supposedly) returns from injured list to make a start for Boston here against former Yankee Clay Holmes for New York.

How are we playing this game with our free baseball betting pick?

MLB Betting Odds

Tuesday’s baseball betting market opened the Mets at around -130 over Boston, with an O/U of 9. Early betting action shaved that line to -125.

Mets-Red Sox Betting Preview

Boston grabbed the opener of this series Monday night 3-1. The Red Sox got all they would need with two runs in the first inning and one in the second and hung on from there.

Boston won Monday as a +105 underdog against Kodai Senga and the game played under a total of 9, as the teams combined to bat 2-19 with RISP.

With Monday’s win, the Red Sox are 2-1 over their last three games. At 24-25 overall, Boston trails Cleveland by 2.5 games in the battle for the No. 6 spot in the American League playoff standings.

With Monday’s loss, New York is 1-4 over its last five games. At 29-19 overall, the Mets now trail first-place Philadelphia by a half-game in the NL East.

These teams met once last season, in September, when the Mets, right at the start of their late-season run, swept three games from the Sox at Citi Field.

Tuesday’s Pitching Match-Up

Buehler is making his first start in almost a month, after doing some time on the IL with a sore shoulder. By our accounting he’s only 2/6 on quality starts this season. However, over his last four outings, including a winning one last time out against Cleveland April 26, he allowed just seven ER and 18 hits through 24 1/3 innings, with eight walks against 22 strikeouts.

Boston is 5-1 with Buehler this season, and he can claim some credit for that.

In his most recent start against the Mets, which came for the Dodgers in the NLCS last year, Buehler worked around three hits, two walks, and one HBP to toss four scoreless innings in an 8-0 Los Angeles victory.

Holmes is two for his last five on quality starts, going all-right as of late. Last Wednesday, against Pittsburgh, he gave up four runs in six innings of a loss of 4-0 Mets. But over his five starts previous to that, he only allowed 6 ER and 21 hits through 28 innings.

New York is 7-2 with Holmes this year, although 6-3 would probably more accurately describe his overall performance.

Last year, while with the Yankees, Holmes made five appearances against the Red Sox, allowing three runs and five hits through five total innings, with one walk against four strikeouts.

Advantage: Mets, but it’s close.

Splits With the Sticks

New York is batting .246 against right-handed pitching this season, with a .325 team OBP and a .414 team slugging percentage. The Mets have also been held to a total of 10 runs over their last six games.

Boston is slashing .248/.317/.423 against RH pitching.

Advantage: A wash.

The Bullpens

The Red Sox bullpen owns a 3.63 ERA this season, along with a 1.25 WHIP and a 2.80 K/BB ratio.

The Mets pen owns a 3.01 ERA, a 1.21 WHIP, and a 2.54 K/BB ratio. Numbers like those lead us to rank this unit among the top half-dozen bullpens in Baseball at the moment.

Advantage: Mets, but it’s close.

MLB Betting Trends

New York is 12-14 on the road this season and 24-14 against RH starters.

Boston is 13-11 at home and 20-19 against RH starters.

Totals Report

The Under is 28-17 in Mets games this season.

The Under is 13-10 at Fenway Park this season.

Prop Bets

New York IF Lindor, who’s 1/22 over his last six games, is catching +115 to hit over 1.5 total bases.

Today's Free MLB Picks

We like the Mets at -125 to get back on track and cash in on the moneyline.

Free Pick: Take the NY Mets -125
Bovada

SOLID 50% BONUS - UP TO $250 FREE!

MLB Free Picks

Bet on Starting Pitcher Value With MLB Five-Inning Lines

Bet on Starting Pitcher Value With MLB Five-Inning Lines

Similar to betting the first half of an NFL football game, an MLB five-inning line covers the first half of action in a baseball game. Since baseball betting lines, in general, are heavily weighted on each team's starting pitcher, their impact on the game's outcome...

Betting MLB Dime Lines at Select Online Sportsbooks

Betting MLB Dime Lines at Select Online Sportsbooks

Baseball is back on the betting board at your favorite online sportsbook. One of the most popular ways to bet on the games is by using the posted money line odds. An MLB money line handicaps the straight-up result for a game by increasing the financial risk to bet on...

Betting MLB Win Totals

Betting MLB Win Totals

One of the most popular betting props ahead of any MLB regular seasons is on the odds for each team’s projected win total. Given that the schedule covers 162 games, there can be a rather wide margin of error in any projected total. Going through the list of each MLB...

The Statinator’s April 25, 2026 MLB Recap: -8.7 Units on a 2-5 Card

Betting the OVER/UNDER on MLB Props for Home Runs and Total Wins

With spring training underway for all 30 MLB teams, there is a renewed interest in betting the posted props for individual player performances in the regular season. Options like which slugger hits the most home runs and which ace has the most wins are fun and...

BEST SPORTSBOOK BONUSES

Stop wasting money! Start receiving at 30% Rebate at Betanysports

YES! There are still online sportsbooks where your credit card will work! You get a 50% bonus as well! –> Bovada

Deposit $100 to $1000 and get a MASSIVE 50% Sign-on bonus! MyBookie